Joomla 1.5 vs. Drupal 6

Right now there are two big CMS systems which have been recently released. As you may or may not know Drupal and Joomla are the two biggest open source CMS solutions. They both have big communites, and both have been used by companies and individuals to make big and important websites. But what the biggest thing that comes to mind is what is the difference between these CMS systems?

New Features for Joomla

The new Joomla 1.5 marks the first Joomla release which gets away from the mambo codebase. It has been completely rewritten from scratch.

Template parameters

Template parameters can be used to let administrators control the template structure. Administrators could switch color schemes, choose between a 2 or 3 column layout … or set the minimum width of the template.

Template Overrides

Simplified changing way an article is rendered and changing the table output to divs. Pagination rendering and module styles can also be extended.

Support for multiple css files

The template manager supports multiple css files and adds support for a special editor.css file that gets loaded by the wysiwyg editor in the administrator.

New Template architecture

It is now possible override all the html generated by the modules and components to suit his needs.
To allow this kind of functionality Joomla! 1.5 implements a solution called a ‘template view‘. Components and modules developed using this new API (application programming interface) can be automatically overridden by template designers. There are now two types of templates: the site templates and the extension templates. A site template defines the look and feel of your website while an extension template defines how a certain component or module gets rendered. The extension templates can be overridden in a site template. PHP code is now the template language of choice to implement presentation logic. patTemplate (the old template language) while still supported is now not used in core (it was slow, and it didn't work with PHP code).

Improved SEF URL implementation

Joomla now has even more capability for search engine friendly URLs. That means that even out of the box joomla can now have a better url than http://your_domain_name.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=1&Itemid=2, something more like http://your_domain_name.com/index.php/About us (yes, that's right with the blank space).

UI Improvements

Joomla has added new perameters to theming elements. They have provided an easy way for themers to incorporate rounded corners. They also have a new menu system for the admin section. They also cleaned up the administrator section, so that it is cleaner. The new Joomla also has more icons and buttons added to the install process. And has ajaxified the installer.

UTF 8 Support

This means that more languages can be used on a Joomla site. And the installer can detect your language.

New Features For Drupal 6.0

Installer

The new Drupal 6 experience starts with the installer, which has been drastically improved. It now guides you through the initial setup steps, so starting a new Drupal site is significantly easier. Configuration parameters that used to be all over the place are now prompted for during the install so there are fewer steps necessary to get the site configured.
Languages

Improved Language Features

You will notice the improved language features as well, in both the installer and throughout using Drupal. Right to left (RTL) languages are now supported, interface translations are automatically imported, and you can translate your posts right from the built-in interface, without installing additional modules.

OpenID

The OpenID client module has been added to core. This allows your users to sign on your site with their OpenID accounts.

Actions and triggers

A new Trigger module has been added to core. The Trigger module lets you assign flexible configurable actions to several events happening on your site (eg. send an email when a post gets published).

Update status

The highly popular Update status module is now in core. This informs you about the latest bug fix and security updates for modules and themes enabled on your site, so you can always keep your site secure and clean.

Menu system

The menu system was rewritten from scratch, making it much more efficient. The menu interface is nearly identical so aside from the performance improvements, you will only notice the underlying changes if you are a programmer.

Theming

Theming has been made more flexible and easier by moving most of PHPTemplate engine deeper into core. Default template files (.tpl.php) can now be implemented by modules and a handful have already been converted. If you don't like the way something looks, just find the .tpl file, copy it to your theme, and change the HTML.

Book and Forum changes

The book module and forum module have been reworked from the ground up: it is now possible to have any type of content in forums (polls for example) and the book administration is simplified.

Caching

There have been significant improvements in drupal caching, this includes the javascript aggregator can greatly increase loadtimes on sites with multiple javascript files.

Breakdown

So as you can see I have laid it all out there the major features with both releases and I leave it up to you to decide. I picked drupal, but it really depends on the project your working on.

If your a developer and would like more information on how to get up to speed with drupal, you can also check out my post on the fundamental concepts of drupal for a php developer.

Related Posts

PHP to Drupal: Get up to speed with drupal from a php developer background

While working on various projects with drupal I realized that there is really no one definitive place which lists the concepts that you need to become familiar with when dealing with drupal. So I decided that I would put them in one place for people who maybe are experienced php developers who are trying to learn to work with drupal for the first time.

Hello .. I have never seen a

Hello .. I have never seen a smart articles that you created. It really helped me to get back my ideas for writing. I will save this post, for I learn more Consultoria RH

Thanks for the tips shared

Thanks for the tips shared on Inspirational Designs for Nike. Thanks for sharing all these wonderful blogposts. One more thing. In my opinion that there are several travel insurance web-sites of dependable companies that permit you to enter a trip details to get you the prices.
search engine optimization service

In this case I would also go

In this case I would also go for drupal,as it seems more familiar than Joomla which is still not used by so many people. I also agree that it totally depends on what you are working on because what works for one person may not work for the other.
The Vineyards Summerlin

It was great that they are

It was great that they are using 2 CMS systems. I really think that it will help them a lot. Joomla's new features are really very good.
xtrema ceramic cookware

Thanks for your article, i

Thanks for your article, i not only like but appreciate you on your article. actually i want to write more but this time i am busy on collect the material about testking mcse for get knowledge more and more. I also offer you to contribute with me for this.

http://bestpanicattackcure.com/natural-cure-pure-calm-review.htm

kflezxftuxftufstpo,

kflezxftuxftufstpo, whgkkgteta

Nursing home

Nursing home Swadlincote
http://www.jasonhyltoncourt.com

Howdy! This is my first

Howdy! This is my first comment here so I just wanted to give a quick shout out and say I genuinely enjoy reading your blog posts. Can you suggest any other blogs/websites/forums that cover the same topics? Appreciate it!bronchitis cure

Howdy! This is my first

Howdy! This is my first comment here so I just wanted to give a quick shout out and say I genuinely enjoy reading your blog posts. Can you suggest any other blogs/websites/forums that cover the same topics? Appreciate it!
bronchitis cure

comment4, aciphex real name,

comment4, aciphex real name, 8-[, aciphex and weight gain, qiyezo, anabolic steroids synthroid pravachol aciphex nasacort, nmg, aciphex patient assistance program, 8), aciphex mail in rebate, 54550,

I think that Drupal much

I think that Drupal much better then Joomla. We always prefer Drupal for creating new websites. Expecially OpenID, Caching and usability in Drupal much better.
Best Regards,
Php Programmer, Eldev software development Company.

Open Source Content

Open Source Content Management Systems is the way to go these days to ensure your clients can update, manage and upload content themselves when it comes to their websites. I have been using Joomla for many years and until I recently discovered Concrete 5, I used to believe Joomla was the best. Concrete 5 is not just clients being able to change the content, but the whole website itself by a few clicks of a button. custom php

I think it is adoring to be

I think it is adoring to be aware of the important difference between these powerful and most popular content management systems. I've found the discussion very good; comprehensive and exhaustive. thanks for sharing. marlene krauss

I've been benefited by the

I've been benefited by the excellent lesson on joomla 1.5 vs drupal 6 and decided to bring my friends to the post for its valuable information. thanks for sharing. campaign buttons

Thanks for the helpful

Thanks for the helpful post...I was facing the same error while coding for my website, I searched a lot for the particular error a lot.. I came across your site and all my doubts got cleared...Thanks a lot again...
stress remedy

I am glad to visit your

I am glad to visit your valuable post on these powerful cms systems and their powerful features. I should recommend the post to my friends for its useful content. It is a refreshing post. media buyers

i have develop one site

i have develop one site using Drupal.. have take a look there....
ms project

i have develop one site

i have develop one site using Drupal. This site about project managament. You have take a look there:
ms project

i have develop one site

i have develop one site using Drupal.. have take a look there:
ms project

i have develop one site

i have develop one site using Drupal.. have take a look there:
http://www.msprojectegitimi.com

It is an excellent

It is an excellent opportunity to land in the post for its relevant content. Drupal and joomla are two of the most powerful content management systems. However, drupal is always preferable to all other cms for numerous reasons. It is a useful information. email marketing

It is an excellent

It is an excellent opportunity to land in the post for its useful content. Drupal and joomla are two of the most popular content management systems. However, drupal is always preferable to all other cms for numerous reasons. It is a useful information. email marketing

I am extremely glad to

I am extremely glad to discover important and interesting features of both joomla 1.5 and drupal 6. It is a valuable discussion on the subject. I've found it to be very educative and informative. It is a nice work. design product

I am glad to discover

I am glad to discover important and interesting features of both joomla 1.5 and drupal 6. It is a valuable discussion on the subject. I've found it to be very educative and informative. It is a nice job. design product

You have done a great job by

You have done a great job by posting the interesting comparison between Joomla 1.5 versus Drupal 6. It has been a blessing for me to learn the essential features of both the platforms. I've enjoyed reading the discussion especially the role PHP to get the speed with drupal. auto salvage

I am glad to learn about the

I am glad to learn about the discussion on Drupal and Joomla which are the two biggest open source CMS solutions and both of them have big community and companies to use. business valuations

I am glad to learn about the

I am glad to learn about the discussion on Drupal and Joomla which are the two biggest open source CMS solutions and both of them have big community and companies to use. evansville housing

Since we have been

Since we have been acquainted with these two biggest open source CMS solutions, we would like to know the difference between these system, so that we can be comfortable in using them to the maximum. free online dating

I've found the discussion on

I've found the discussion on Joomla 1.5 vs. Drupal 6 very interesting, informative and instructive. I would like visit the post its relevance and usefulness. sell a business

any idea of joomla blog

any idea of joomla blog comment?

I tried both drupal and

I tried both drupal and joomla, but decided wp is more my cup of tea. much easier.
Martin

When was the post published?

When was the post published? Is it up to date?

We tried drupal for clients

We tried drupal for clients at first but ended up going with Joomla 1.5 for our church website design clients. Their interface is a lot more user-friendly and the number of extentions beats drupal by far.

The article is really

The article is really awesome, and I get lots of information from the article, it’s really very helpful for the blogger. commercial cleaning chicago

Thanks for your article, i

Thanks for your article, i not only like but appreciate you on your article. actually i want to write more but this time i am busy on collect the material about testking mcse for get knowledge more and more. I also offer you to contribute with me for this.
have a nice day
Albert

Very informative and

Very informative and trustworthy blog. Please keep updating with great posts like this one. I have booked marked your site and am about to email it to a few friends of mine that I know would enjoy reading Arkadaslik sitesi - Sohbet Odalari

Joomla the best!! but, the

Joomla the best!!
but, the lack of different user levels a major concern!!

Joomla the best!! but, the

Joomla the best!!
but, the lack of different user levels a major concern!!

I’m hoping to start

I’m hoping to start running my own online bible study course but need to get a better understanding of these systems first. Drupal 6 looks like it should be more universally accessible and simpler for me to use so far.

Great and useful info, but I

Great and useful info, but I myself prefer Joomla as it seems much easier to modifying it...

That's all is fine. In

That's all is fine. In comparison of bothe which one is more suitable for a matrimony site? If someone can pl suggest I will be grateful. Thanks!

thanks for the comparison.

thanks for the comparison. you were honest about your preference for Drupal and that is appreciated. Those who have an affinity for Joomla would do well to right up a comparison of their own. by the way i started out on Joomla for my site. but see the value of Drupal and, no doubt, will use Drupal when necessary.

i have develop one site

i have develop one site using Drupal.. have take a look there:

http://www.kripkornstudios.com.my/

This is great information.

This is great information. Choosing the right CMS for you is very important. I'm conducting a survey on the relative strengths and weaknesses of Joomla! and Drupal . I think the question, “what CMS is best for X,” comes up a lot.

To address this issue, I’ve created a survey about how well both Drupal and Joomla implement a number of common website requirements, like ease-of-use, blogging features, etc.

Your opinion is important. A survey of a broad cross-section of professionals will hopefully lead to some interesting insights. So, if you have experience with either CMS please take our survey.

Refer to my blog to learn more about the purpose of this survey.

Good post but as already

Good post but as already said, what's up with the spam? Why not try using something like Mollom or Askimet?

Cleaned up the spam. This

Cleaned up the spam. This site does use mollum :) If I didn't use mollum, I definitly would not have open comments.

Solid review. what is up

Solid review. what is up with all the spam in your comments?

Rstanley - http://robertmstanley.com

I believe you have not done

I believe you have not done justice to Joomla by not including the fact that the CMS uses MVC (model View Controller)within the framework.

We just started using the

We just started using the Joomla 1.5 system and have been very pleased with its versatility. church website design

Post new comment